- Trade down
- Draft Ndomikong Suh
- Draft a LT (Russell Okung or Trent Williams being the likely candidates)
Option 2 is what might happen, for a number of reasons but the balance needs to be struck between:
- How many snaps is a DT drafted that high going to play? This boils down to whether you're convinced that Suh can play the undertackle/3-technique on run downs and nose tackle/1-technique on passing downs, while being effective at both positions?
- Is the DT a fit for the Lions scheme. I'd argue Gerard McCoy is not a fit because he's more of a one-gap penetrating tackle who fits better in a traditional 4-3. But the Lions run a 4-3 that operates on 3-4 principles where your DTs have to eat up blockers and try to collapse lanes. This would mean that your two-gap tackles are likely to be a better schematic fit, meaning players like Suh (or if they trade back Dan Williams) should be the targets.
- Are you convinced that Suh's knees are healthy (2 surgeries - one for meniscus tear as a freshman, one that was precautionary)?
- Does this improve the talent on the roster enough to justify the pick?
LDE Jason Hunter, Jared Devries, (Cliff Avril), (Andre Fluellen)
3DT Corey Williams, Andre Fluellen, Joe Cohen
1DT Sammie Hill, (Corey Williams), Landon Cohen, Terrence Taylor
RDE Kyle Vanden Bosch, Cliff Avril, Turk McBride, Copeland Bryan
In contrast to last year this would mean they've got options and talent for their scheme (ex. White wasn't a good fit to set the edge of the pocket for the run game or QB scrambles, whereas Vanden Bosch should be). Personally I think improving upon the bottom of their game day rotation (Fluellen or MCBride) with a top-rung impact player that can help them to hold the line of attack and really open up the LBs is a solid option. This would go further to solidify their run defense further and help to keep their secondary out of as much trouble as they had last year when no opposing QB worried about being able to step up in the pocket.
Of course, the fall back plan is Option 3 - which is what will happen if they aren't convinced that a DT is right for them. Ideally this would provide them with:
- An excellent pass-blocking young tackle
- Options at LT (Backus vs rookie), RT (Cherilus vs Backus), and LG (Backus vs Sims vs Loper)
- More stability on offense, which is statistically more consistant from year to year.
- Less of a money issue as OT is already a premium money position